EMAIL: info@okeno-ip.jp
No. 165; Section 3-1-3, 4-1-16: descriptiveness and misdescriptiveness
refusal;
“OLYMPIA” for metal materials for building or construction, etc.;
Appeal No. 2015-3918(October 6, 2015)
Bottom line: The Board found that “OLYMPIA” is descriptive with respect to metal materials
for building or construction, etc.
The applicant filed a
trademark application for “OLYMPIA” in standard character designating metal
materials for building or construction, metal hardware, metallic hinge in Class
6.
The examiner refused
the application on the grounds as follows:
- Olympia is an ancient
city in Greece, the birthplace of Olympic Games, registered as a world cultural
heritage and is a popular sightseeing spot.
So, consumers and traders will regard the goods bearing the applied-for
mark as those produced or sold in Olympia.
The mark will not function as a source identifier.
- The mark is
misdescriptive of the quality of goods when used for goods other than those
produced or sold in Olympia.
- Thus, the mark falls under Section 3-1-3 and 4-1-16 of the Trademark
Act.
The Board reviewed the
applied-for mark and found as follows:
- Olympia is a popular
sightseeing spot. The applied-for mark
“OLYMPIA” will be recognized as the place where the designated goods are
produced or sold because it is a well-known geographical name. Thus, the mark falls under Section 3-1-3 of
the Trademark Act.
Whereas, the applicant
argued as follows:
- Japanese consumers
and traders will not recognize that industrial goods such as the metallic hinges
are produced or sold in Olympia because Olympia is known as a sightseeing spot
having the remains of ancient Greece.
- Many word marks
“Olympia” or its transliteration in katakana have been
registered.
The Board did not agree
to the applicant’s argument on the ground as follows:
- Japanese consumers
and traders are not familiar with any industry in Olympia other than the
tourism. So, they may presume that the
designated goods are produced or sold in Olympia. The fact that Olympia is a popular
sightseeing spot does not support that the consumers and traders would not
presume industrial goods are not produced or sold in
Olympia.
- The mark is regarded
descriptive if most of consumers and traders presume the goods bearing the mark
are produced or sold in Olympia. It is
not necessary that the goods bearing the mark are actually produced or sold in
Olympia.
Dojima NS Bldg. 3F, 2-1-18, Dojima
Kita-ku, Osaka 530-0003 Japan
TEL: +81-6-6343-8401
FAX: +81-6-6343-8402
Email: info@okeno-ip.jp